Charred and Chopped Broccoli Grilled Cheese: Roasted broccoli florets and spicy peppers chopped and stuffed inside a grilled cheese with gooey cheddar cheese!

Charred and Chopped Broccoli Grilled Cheese

Over the last week or so I watched the SNL 40 year anniversary show in small segments when I could find the time. I’ve loved so many SNL bits over the years.

My favorite thing about the special was how they brought back characters and small moments of old skits throughout the show.

My personal favorite: Dana Carvey singing The Lady I Know (aka Choppin’ Broccoli). This skit used to be impossible to find on the Internet but now Yahoo (in maybe it’s first solid move ever) has purchased and published huge archives of SNL skits.

So now awesome skits like this are easily available. Let’s all take a minute and make our Mondays better with this classic!

Anyway, watching that skit a dozen times in a row made me want to chop some broccoli and put it in a grilled cheese.

Charred and Chopped Broccoli Grilled Cheese: Roasted broccoli florets and spicy peppers chopped and stuffed inside a grilled cheese with gooey cheddar cheese!

Broccoli Cheddar Grilled Cheese

Just a moment please...

3-4 sandwiches
Prep Time
Total Time

Broccoli cheddar grilled cheese with slightly charred and chopped broccoli florets, gooey cheddar cheese, and spicy peppers!


2 big stalks broccoli, chopped
2 Fresno peppers, sliced thin
1 clove garlic, chopped
2 tablespoons olive oil
Salt and pepper
6-8 ounces cheddar cheese
8 slices sandwich or sourdough bread
Unsalted butter, for cooking
Print Recipe     Pin Recipe


1) Preheat oven to 450 degrees F. Cut florets off of broccoli stalks and spread out on a baking sheet with sliced Fresno peppers and garlic. Drizzle with olive oil and season with salt and pepper.

2) Roast veggies until they are charred on the edges, about 15 minutes.

3) After veggies roast, roughly chop them and stir together with cheddar cheese. I prefer to cube my cheese into small cubes, but you could also grate it.

4) Heat a sturdy skillet over medium heat and lightly butter your bread slices. Place the slices butter-side down on the skillet and pile on some of the broccoli mixture.

5) Cover with a second piece of bread, butter-side up. Cook the sandwich until the bread is toasted and the cheese is very melted, about 5 minutes per side. Keep a close eye on the sandwiches to avoid burning the bread. Flip the sandwich if it is cooking too quickly.

Serve sandwiches while warm and chop in half for easier eating.

Broccoli Cheddar Grilled Cheese Prep

For broccoli to work in a grilled cheese, it has to be babied a bit. You can just chop up some florets, stuff it in a sandwich, and call it a day. Having that sandwich is why people hate broccoli.

Doing it right means first roasting the broccoli at a blazing 450 degrees F. with a good drizzle of oil and salt and pepper. You want to really caramelize the vegetable.

I tossed in some sliced Fresno peppers and a garlic clove for extra flavor and some heat.

Veggies for broccoli cheddar grilled cheese.

Ready to roast.

After about 15 minutes in a hot oven, you’ll have some really nice roasted veggies. The little crispy bits around the edges are where it’s at.

Charred veggies for broccoli cheddar grilled cheese.


Now um… chop some broccoli!

Seriously. It’s best in a sandwich if it’s chopped pretty fine so get to it. Chop up the peppers and mince the garlic also! This mix is sandwich-ready now.

Chopped broccoli for grilled cheese.

Choppin’ broccoli!

Cheese Talk

When it comes to cheese for grilled cheese there is an easy option: grating the cheese. Grated cheese melts the fastest and so you don’t run the risk of having unmelted cheese and burned toast.

But, if you have good grilled cheese skills and can control your cooking temperature, try this: Cube the cheese into small cubes.

It takes longer for the cheese to melt when it’s in cubes like this, but then you get these awesome pockets of gooey cheese in your sandwich. It’s a little bit more advanced, but worth the fuss!

Cheese for grilled cheese.

Cubed is good.

Cooking the Broccoli Cheddar Grilled Cheese

When it comes to cooking this sucker, I recommend using a sturdy piece of bread, like a sourdough. Brush the bread slices with a little butter and cook the sandwich over medium or medium-low heat. Pile on the filling and then top off the sandwich.

STarting broccoli cheddar grilled cheese.

Piled high.

The nightmare scenario when cooking a grilled cheese is to blast the sandwich with heat and burn the bread, but still have a cold filling. So it’s really best to err on the side of low heat.

It’s okay to cook it for 5-6 minutes per side if your heat is low. That’s a much better option than 30 seconds per side in a blazing skillet.

Cooking it over lower heat will melt the cheese and give you that beautiful golden color crust.

Broccoli grilled cheese cooked.

Golden brown.

Chop it. Eat it. Repeat.

Charred and Chopped Broccoli Grilled Cheese: Roasted broccoli florets and spicy peppers chopped and stuffed inside a grilled cheese with gooey cheddar cheese!

5 comments on “Charred and Chopped Broccoli Grilled Cheese

  1. OMG, that is one of my favorite SNL skits ever…I STILL sing that damn catchy tune every time I make broccoli! I think I was about 10 when it first came out – idk what I was doing watching SNL at that age, but I remember trying to describe the skit to my mom and just cracking UP as I tried to explain it…great memories!

  2. I love the earlier SNLs & Dana Carvey is SO talented! I’m looking forward to finding that special somewhere. This recipe sounds delicious! Broccoli & cheese are awesome of course, but I never thought of putting it into a toastie! Sometimes (actually, a lot of the time) your recipes just blow my mind!

    1. Oh thanks! :)
      I think you can find the special on Hulu, but i’m not sure if you have to be a Hulu Plus member or not to watch the whole thing.

      1. Apparently Hulu can only be watched in the US but I’ll get my hubby to find it. Meanwhile, broccoli grilled cheese is on our menu this week :-)

Leave a Comment