Porter Braised Brisket
Porter Braised BrisketJump to Recipe
I was excited and worried when Porter Braised Brisket won last week’s poll. I was excited because I would get to eat Porter braised brisket. I was worried because I wasn’t sure that I would actually have enough time to make it and post it by today.
I was right to be excited. I was wrong to be worried.
As far as briskets go, I haven’t had too many braised ones actually. I usually eat them smoked, but that might change. Slow cooking a brisket for many hours in a rich Porter sauce makes for a really amazing fall dish.
It should go without saying that this lovely dish is not a weeknight afterthought meal. This is a meal you need to plan for, but don’t worry. It will pay back dividends for your planning.
The original recipe called for a 6-7 pound brisket and you could even get a much larger brisket if you ordered a full one from a butcher (probably in the 12 pound range). I just couldn’t justify cooking that amount of food when I’m basically cooking for two people (although a very helpful neighbor did stop by to help us put a dent in this on day one.)
I decided to pare down the recipe and use a 4 pound brisket and I think that was about as big as my kitchen equipment could handle. But if I had the right pans, I would make a larger version next time just because it turned out so perfectly wonderful and would be great leftovers for sandwiches and stuff.
Porter Braised Brisket
- Serves 4-6
- Prep Time:
- Total Time:
Did you make this?
Snap a photo and tag @macheesmo so I can see your work.
1) Make the dry rub by mixing together all the ingredients in a bowl. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Trim off some fat from the brisket.
2) Take spice rub and cover brisket with it on both sides.
3) In a large heavy roasting pan, heat a few Tablespoons of oil. When it is really hot, put the brisket in and sear it well on both sides. This should take about 5 minutes per side.
4) Once you pull the brisket out, add 2 Cups of chicken stock to the pan. Use a spatula to stir up any little burned bits stuck to the pan.
5) Once chicken stock is simmering, add prunes, brown sugar, bay leaf, and Porter. Bring that mixture to a boil.
6) Set brisket in this liquid, fat side up. Then layer all those sliced onions on top of the brisket with the garlic cloves! Cook this, covered, for one hour.
7) Take it out and you should see that the onions have turned translucent.
8) Turn the brisket over and push all of the onions into the braising liquid. Cook this uncovered for 30 minutes.
9) Add another cup of chicken broth, cover it and cook it for another 90 minutes.
10) Meanwhile, prepare mushrooms and carrots. You want pretty large pieces or they will just disintegrate.
11) After the 90 minutes, take the brisket out and add the other veggies and one more cup of chicken broth. Set the brisket back on top of the veggies so the veggies are mostly submerged in the braising liquid. Cook this for another 45 minutes with the lid on.
12) Let it cool at room temperature for at least 30 minutes, then let it sit in the fridge for at least 24 – 48 hours.
13) 24 – 48 hours later, get a spoon and gentle spoon off as much fat as you can. Don’t worry about getting all of it.
14) Lift the brisket out of the pot and put the pot with the sauce and veggies over high heat. You want it simmering nicely!
15) Slice the brisket against the grain. Lay out all the slices in a large baking dish.
16) Once the sauce and veggies has come to a simmer, very carefully pour it over the cold brisket slices. Cover this with foil and bake it for yet another 75 minutes at 350 degrees.
17) Finally. Once that baking is done, you can eat it up! Serve up a few slices with all the veggies and sauce.
Making the rub
Make the dry rub by mixing together all the ingredients in a bowl. Note that they amounts above are for the 4 pound brisket I had. Adjust if you are using a larger one. Also, now would be a good time to preheat your oven to 350 degrees.
Preparing the brisket
Depending on where you get your brisket from and what size you get, you might need to trim off some fat from the brisket. The fatty side of the brisket should have an even layer of fat. Trim off any extra. Don’t worry too much about getting it perfect.
Then take your spice rub and cover your brisket with it on both sides. In a large heavy roasting pan (I used my cast iron pot which was only big enough for a 4 pound brisket), heat a few Tablespoons of oil. When it is really hot, put the brisket in and sear it well on both sides. Should take about 5 minutes per side.
Prepping the liquid
Once your pull your brisket out, add 2 Cups of chicken stock to the pan. It will hiss! Use a spatula to stir up any little burned bits stuck to the pan. That’s all flavor. Once your chicken stock is simmering, add your prunes, brown sugar, bay leaf, and Porter. Bring that mixture to a boil.
Preparing the braise
Next, set your brisket in this liquid, fat side up. Then layer all those sliced onions on top of the brisket with your garlic cloves! It’s okay if you lose a few onions into the liquid. Just get them all in the pot.
Cook this, covered, for one hour. Then take it out and you should see that the onions have turned translucent.
Turn the brisket over and push all of the onions into the braising liquid.
Cook this uncovered for 30 minutes. Then add another cup of chicken broth, cover it and cook it for another 90 minutes. This is the definition of slow cooking here people…
Meanwhile, prepare your mushrooms and carrots. You want pretty large pieces or they will just disintegrate.
After the 90 minutes, take the brisket out and add the other veggies and one more cup of chicken broth. Set the brisket back on top of the veggies so the veggies are mostly submerged in the braising liquid.
Cook this for another 45 minutes with the lid on.
After that, you should end up with a very tender piece of meat and a stew of veggies in a really rich sauce. It’ll look about like this:
Oh the waiting…
Here’s the hard part. This needs to sit in the fridge for at least 24 hours. I let mine sit for 48 hours. One note, make sure to let it cool at room temperature for at least 30 minutes before sticking it in your fridge.
After a day or two you’ll pull out something that looks much different. Don’t worry. All of the deliciousness is still intact.
There will be a decent layer of fat that has congealed on the surface. It’s not attractive and won’t really help your final cause. Get a spoon and gentle spoon off as much as you can. Don’t worry about getting all of it.
Then lift your brisket out of your pot and put the pot with the sauce and veggies over high heat. You want it simmering nicely!
Meanwhile, slice your brisket against the grain. It will be really easy to slice if you do it while it’s cold. Then lay out all the slices in a large baking dish.
See all those little veins in each slice? Those are little veins of fat and as the brisket warms up, they will melt and make for a wonderfully tender finished product.
Once your sauce and veggies has come to a simmer, very carefully pour it over your cold brisket slices. It might be a tight fit depending on your pan size!
Cover this with foil and bake it for yet another 75 minutes at 350 degrees.
Finally. Once that baking is done, you can eat it up! Serve up a few slices with all the veggies and sauce. I can’t even explain in words how tender and flavorful this was.
Here’s the kind of cool thing about this dish. I made it on a Sunday morning and ate it on a Tuesday night. I watched football while it cooked. There really isn’t a lot of work involved with it. Just a lot of time. Then I just did the reheating step on Tuesday night and it made for a perfect weeknight dinner.
I mean this stuff was amazing. It was a great combination between a very tender steak and a delicious pot roast. I had it for leftovers in sandwich form and just sliced. It’s amazing no matter what.
I wish I had 4 more pounds of the stuff.
About MacheesmoRead More
Hello! My name is Nick Evans and I write and manage Macheesmo. I started Macheesmo 11 years ago when I was just learning my way around the kitchen. I love to cook and love everything food-related, but I have no formal training. These days I focus on fast, accessible recipes with the occasional “reach” recipe!
I’ve posted almost 2,000 recipes on Macheesmo. For each one, I do my best to give full explanations of what I did and tips on what I’d do differently next time. I’ll bring up the tricky parts and the easy parts.
I hope you can find something and cook something!
19 Responses to “Porter Braised Brisket” Leave a comment
I'd trade you my lunch for this.
Looks great and tender and perfect for the cooler weather we are having.
That does look mighty satisfying… GREG
wow. this looks amazing. i just found your blog and am excited to keep reading. I hope i can learn to cook one day! ha ha !! :)
you know what I love about dishes likes these? the next couple days afterwards there is this lingering smell in the house of roast and onions….I know I'm weird, but love it.
there better have been bread w/ this to sop it all up? hello?
This looks AMAZING! I love all of the veggies that you put with it too….this over mashed potatoes- yum!
What do you think about adapting this for a crockpot? This seems like a great recipe to adapt to this type of cooking….except for the resting & fat skimming parts. What are your thoughts? Would you ever try this in a crockpot & if so, how would you do it?
Thanks and congrats on your nomination!
Holy crap Nick. Slow cooked beef in a good beer may be my favorite things on Earth.
I'm curious why you keep the garlic and onions dry on top of the brisket for an hour. I can't imagine the broth or the onions themselves are much different whether they're in for 4.5 vs 5.5 hours. So is it to get a good strong onion + garlic flavor onto the surface of the meat itself?
If you can't tell I'm intrigued… :)
I remember watching a chili cook-off in which a contestant said using one or two prunes in their chili thickened and colored the sauce, but they removed them at the end. Maybe that helped here?
@Kaitlyn. Yep I think you could… You'd have to have at least a 5 or 6 qt. crockpot. Also, I'm not sure it would get hot enough for the browning part so you may have to do that seperately. Then you could add the ingredients to the crockpot and you'd probably need to cook it longer than in the oven. Maybe 6-8 hours. I'm not a crockpot expert but that's what I'd do.
@Caleb. The honest answer is that I did it because the original recipe said to. I'm not sure at all why it makes a difference. My only GUESS is that as the onions cook, their moisture drips onto the brisket which flavors it directly. I'm not sure how much of a difference it makes though..
Oh freaken yum! We are stuck with leftover homemade lasagna. I want this instead! Sniff, Sniff
Just a note that the "brown sugar" is listed in the ingredients section but I didn't see it used in the directions anywhere.
Making this and the biscuits this weekend… can't wait to try them!
Hey Josh! Good point. Post updated. You add the brown sugar along with the bay leaf,Porter, etc for the braising liquid.
Wow your quick on the reply. Thanks for the info, I cooked it yesterday should be ready by tonight, I can't wait. Used Old Dominion Oak Barrel stout, which was recommended by my favorite bartender here and while it was hard not to drink it straight outta the bottle, I am looking forward to having it with my beef!
Hi! I’m actually in the process of cooking this right now and it smells amazing, but I realized there’s no specification on when to add the Dijon mustard and red wine vinegar. Thanks for a great recipe!
Hey Andrea! You want to add those to the braise when you add the veggies, but honestly you could add them at any point. It’s flexible! Good luck!
CAN I USE SOMETHING ELSE THAN PORTER BEER? I AM ALLERGIC TO YEAST AND MOST BEERS HAVE YEAST.
You can sub red wine. Good luck!
Red wine has yeast too, but you could use all beef stock instead. Try adding a tsp instant coffee powder as well…adds colour and richness…Great recipe!!
Gonna cold smoke mine 1st then add it to my Dutch pot. Like the wine add instead of beer. Will serve for the panthers game