Stuffed Sweet Peppers: Whipped goat cheese and spicy hummus layered in crunchy, crisp sweet peppers and topped with various garnishes. The perfect, quick summer appetizer!
Easy Eats

Double Layer Stuffed Sweet Peppers

This post is brought to you by Sabra Dipping Co, LLC.. All opinions are 100% mine. Today is National Hummus Day! Sabra has some fun plans to celebrate the day so stop by their National Hummus day page to follow along! Also, be sure to Like Sabra on Facebook for lots of great recipes and giveaways!

It’s not rocket science to serve some appetizers in the summer. Pop open some salsa or mix up some quick guacamole. But, what if you need something that’s just a tiny bit classier? I’m not talking black tie affair, but maybe you’re cooking for coworkers or family and you want to show off a bit.

But you also probably don’t want to do things like A) turn on the oven or B) actually do much work.

So, umm… these. This time of year you can find these big packs of tiny sweet peppers in markets and stores for a few bucks. They are super crunchy and colorful and perfect appetizer size. I recommend stuffing them full of whipped goat cheese and spicy hummus.

You should try it because you trust me. Right?!

2 dozen peppers
Prep Time
Total Time

Just a moment please...


Stuffed Sweet Peppers

Goat cheese stuffed sweet peppers with a creamy, spicy hummus layer and lots of fun garnish toppings. The perfect, quick summer appetizer!


2 dozen small sweet peppers
6 ounces goat cheese
1/3 cup cream
Salt and pepper
10 ounces spicy hummus
Pine nuts, toasted (garnish)
Chives (garnish)
Red fresno peppers (garnish)

Helpful Equipment

Mixer Hand Mixer
Print Recipe  


1) For whipped goat cheese, combine goat cheese, cream, and a pinch of salt and pepper in a mixing bowl. Use a stand mixer with the paddle attachment or a hand mixer to whip the mixture until smooth. If it’s not getting smooth, add a bit more cream. The finished mixture should be the consistency of frosting.

2) Lay out washed sweet peppers on a tray and cut a slice off the top of each pepper (leave the stems intact). Scoop out any seeds in the peppers.

3) Scoop the whipped goat cheese into a plastic bag. Seal it and slice a corner off the bag. Pipe the goat cheese into each pepper.

4) Mix spicy hummus together and scoop it into a second plastic bag. Pipe the hummus on top of the goat cheese layer.

Top each pepper with fresh chives, thinly sliced red peppers, or lightly toasted pine nuts. Serve immediately or chill for a few hours. They are best served the same day.

Goat Cheese Stuffed Sweet Peppers

Sweet and Spicy

You might think, at first glance, that the peppers are spicy. They aren’t the slightest bit spicy. In a tastebud switcheroo, the hummus is actually the spicy part. In one bite you get crunchy, sweet, creamy, tangy, and spicy. It’s an all-purpose appetizer bite.

Sweet peppers for stuffing.

These guys.

You could use any hummus, but I’m a huge fan of the Supremely spicy version that Sabra makes. I’m a spicy nut and love heat, and this doesn’t disappoint. They top the hummus with a huge mound of spicy chili mix that I recommend stirring it into the hummus so you don’t get it all in one bite.

Supremely spicy hummus.

Seriously spicy.

Whipped Goat Cheese

Okay. Let’s talk goat cheese. Of course, you could just spread some goat cheese into each pepper, but the tiny extra step of whipping it first actually makes it easier to layer in the peppers and makes each bite really creamy.

Whipped goat cheese stuffed sweet peppers.

The goat cheese mix.

Whip the goat cheese with some cream, salt, and pepper. You can use a stand mixer or hand mixer to get the job done.

When it’s the consistency of a sturdy frosting, it’s ready to go.

Whipped cheese.

Nice and smooth.

Pepper Prep

To get the peppers ready to stuff, don’t cut off the stems! They are pretty and also make for easier grabbing. Instead, lay the peppers flat on a sheet and cut a slice off the top of each pepper. Then scoop out the seeds (there won’t be too many seeds).

To lay down the whipped goat cheese layer, scoop the mixture into a plastic bag and cut the corner off. This is my quick and dirty piping bag.

Stuffing sweet peppers.

Make it pretty.

Then just fill all the peppers! You can use a good amount in each pepper, but remember that we have another layer to go.

Goat cheese stuffed sweet peppers.

Easy stuff.

To make them pretty, do the same thing with the hummus. Scoop it into a plastic bag and then pipe it onto the peppers. Again, I think it actually ends up being faster than trying to spread on the hummus and it looks cool!

Goat cheese stuffed sweet peppers.

Quick hummus layer.

Toppings Galore

The goat cheese stuffed sweet peppers are good just like that honestly, but if you want to take it a step further, there are lots of great garnishes you could add. I did three versions: one with toasted pine nuts, one with thinly sliced fresno peppers, and one with minced chives. Pretty much any fresh her or toasted nut would go well on these guys.

I ate like six of these right away. They are addictive and just fancy enough.

Make them the next time you need something special, you show off.

Stuffed Sweet Peppers: Whipped goat cheese and spicy hummus layered in crunchy, crisp sweet peppers and topped with various garnishes. The perfect, quick summer appetizer!

4 comments on “Double Layer Stuffed Sweet Peppers

  1. Will be making these the next time I have to bring something to a social with hubby’s co-workers. Look easy to do and will be very colourful oh a serving tray. Plus, different than the usual fare.

  2. These look great ! Will be making them for the next social event we are invited too. Different than the usual fare and will look very nice on the serving tray. Thanks !

  3. I love these little peppers, they are so crunchy, sweet and versatile! But, this will take them over the top!!! Like you, we love spicy!!!!!!

Leave a Comment