Confident home cooking
peach grilled cheese
Main Dishes, Quick and Easy, Sandwiches, Vegetarian

Peach Grilled Cheese

by Nick

I was really itchin’ for a grilled cheese over the weekend but after my last sort of failed grilled cheese, I needed inspiration from others. So I sent out a Tweet and figured I’d get some delicious ideas from the Tweople. I got some really great suggestions!

Here’s a few of the suggested ideas:

  • @christianrock28 a caprese salad grilled cheese. Like tomatoes mozzarella cheese and basil. -Anita
  • @vanillakitchen love it w corn relish in middle
  • @rosscott Smoothie! (I thought and thought about it but couldn’t master the physics of it…)
  • @onmaggiesfarm maybe something sweet? like challah with ricotta or chevre honey and sliced peaches.

The peach theme was close, but at the end of the day, the winner was:

I wanted it immediately.

Serves 2.
Prep Time
Total Time
Print Recipe

Peach Grilled Cheese

Peach Grilled Cheese


  • 4 slices of rustic bread (I used a sourdough loaf)
  • 2 very ripe peaches, peeled and sliced
  • 4-6 ounces Gruyere cheese, sliced
  • Handful of arugula
  • Butter


1) Peel and slice your peaches, slice the cheese, slice and lightly butter the bread.

2) Using a large skillet or non-stick pan, add a slice of bread, buttered side down for each sandwich.  Put a layer of peaches and cheese on each slice.  Top with arugula and the top piece of bread, buttered side up.

3) Cook over medium to medium-low heat, occasionally flipping until the bread is browned and the cheese is really melted.  Gooey melted.  Keep an eye on it to make sure the bread doesn't burn.  This will probably take 8-10 minutes.

4) Serve immediately.

The Ingredients

The flavors in this sandwich are kind of out of this world. There are only three ingredients, but they go perfectly together.

sandwich ingredients

Accidental Face!

You’ll also want some really sturdy bread for this sandwich. Wonder bread will not do the trick. Hunt out a good rustic loaf of bread or use some no knead bread if you have some. I found a really nice loaf of sourdough from my local farmer’s market (also got the peaches from there).


Wonder bread is a no-no here people.

Peeling the peaches

Peaches can be kind of tricky to peel because they’re a bit slippery. There are two techniques for this.

First, you can brave them with a good veggie peeler or a paring knife. This is what I did and it works okay. You just need a steady hand.

Second, you can dunk the guys in boiling water for a few seconds and then run them under cold water. The fuzzy peel should slide right off. Of course, for this technique you have to boil some water which adds on to your time.

Either method will work though.

In any event, get all your ingredients ready before you start making the sandwich. That means slice the peaches, slice the cheese, and lightly butter one side of every slice of bread.

all sliced

All ready to go!

Cooking the Sandwich

You can cook a grilled cheese in almost anything (or even on a grill). I’ve done it in a normal skillet, a cast iron skillet, and a non-stick pan. I used a large non-stick pan for this sandwich.

The key, in my opinion, to a good grilled cheese sandwich is to use medium to medium-low heat. If you crank up the heat too high, then the bread will be completely burned before the cheese is melted. A low heat allows time for the heat to transfer through the bread and melt the cheese.

I started by putting my pan over medium heat and then added two slices of bread, the peaches, and then the cheese.

Just kind of layer it so it looks nice and even.

making a sandwich

Not really rocket science.

Then add a handful of arugula and the top piece of bread, butter side up.

Keep a close eye on your sandwich. Baby it. It’s probably the most important thing you’ll cook all day.

After a few minutes, give the sandwich a flip with a big spatula. The sandwich will be sturdier as the cheese melts, but this first flip might be a little tricky. You might need to use your extra hand to hold the sandwich together as you flip it.

If things slide around a bit, you can fix it after the flip.


I flipped out.

These sandwiches will probably take anywhere from 8-10 minutes to cook. Again, don’t get in a hurry. If you’re bread is browning too much on one side, flip it over to give that side a rest and turn down the heat a bit.

As with any grilled cheese, the sandwich is done when the cheese is gooey!

Eat this as soon as possible!

perfect sandwich

No big deal. I just rule.

As with any sandwich grilled cheese I make, I need to rate this bad boy.

Cheesiness: 9. Melted Gruyere is one of my favorite cheeses. Sure it’s a bit expensive, but it’s really delicious and melts perfectly.
Bread: 9. Sourdough is a great grilled cheese bread. It easily held up to the fillings and browned nicely.
Fillings: 9. Perfect. Summer. Fillings.
Overall: 9. This was one of the best grilled cheeses I’ve made. As good if not slightly better than the Brie and Pesto Sandwich.

If you can get your hands on some good peaches, this is a solid use for them!